AIDS Rethinking was again disseminated to mainstream researchers, this time at the65th Annual Congress of the Italian Society for Anatomy and Histology in Padua, 27-29 September 2011.
An extensive poster presentation (authors: Ruggiero, Pacini, Punzi, Morucci, Gulisano, Köhnlein, Bauer) discussed “The Clinical Significance of Immune-System Laboratory Tests”. The poster makes the following salient points:
→ Scientists accept conclusions of experts in fields outside their own specialties. The resulting mainstream “consensus” can remain unchanged for a long time even after the experts have modified or discarded their earlier conclusions.
→ That is so with HIV/AIDS, where evidence has accumulated that the original hypothesis was wrong:
An extensive poster presentation (authors: Ruggiero, Pacini, Punzi, Morucci, Gulisano, Köhnlein, Bauer) discussed “The Clinical Significance of Immune-System Laboratory Tests”. The poster makes the following salient points:
→ Scientists accept conclusions of experts in fields outside their own specialties. The resulting mainstream “consensus” can remain unchanged for a long time even after the experts have modified or discarded their earlier conclusions.
→ That is so with HIV/AIDS, where evidence has accumulated that the original hypothesis was wrong:
♦ Kaposi’s sarcoma is not caused by HIV.
♦ Many clinical AIDS cases were found to be HIV-negative
(and renamed — entirely ad hoc — “idiopathic CD4-T-cell lymphopenia”).
♦ Anti-retroviral drugs often cause clinical deterioration instead of
helping patients recover (“immune restoration syndrome”).
Patients on Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy (HAART)
experience more adverse non-AIDS events than AIDS events.
♦ “HIV” tests are anything but specific; false-positives arise from a host of conditions
that are not necessarily health-threatening.
♦ CD4 counts are not a good biomarker of clinical condition, nor a criterion of illness,
still less a reason for instituting HAART.
♦ Many clinical AIDS cases were found to be HIV-negative
(and renamed — entirely ad hoc — “idiopathic CD4-T-cell lymphopenia”).
♦ Anti-retroviral drugs often cause clinical deterioration instead of
helping patients recover (“immune restoration syndrome”).
Patients on Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy (HAART)
experience more adverse non-AIDS events than AIDS events.
♦ “HIV” tests are anything but specific; false-positives arise from a host of conditions
that are not necessarily health-threatening.
♦ CD4 counts are not a good biomarker of clinical condition, nor a criterion of illness,
still less a reason for instituting HAART.